Spotters
Shades Distributors (USA)
2 Ryers Avenue
Ground Floor
Cheltenham, PA, 19012
• T:
215.379.1080
• F:
215.379.1082
•
info@spotters-shades.com
|
|
There are two basic lens
materials that sunglass can be made from: 1)
Glass and 2)
Plastic.
The most popular plastics are: a) CR-39 and
b) Polycarbonate
Each lens material has advantages and disadvantages. Here are
the facts:
|
| |
PROS |
CONS |
| Glass |
The only material that can be made into 100% optically correct eyewear. |
Most expensive lenses. |
| |
Best scratch resistance. |
Heaviest lens material. |
| |
|
click here for more about Glass |
| CR-39 |
Good
scratch resistance. |
Can
chip like glass. |
| |
Good
optical clarity. |
Cannot be made
into 100% optically correct sunglasses. |
| |
|
click
here for more about CR-39 |
| Polycarbonate |
Shatter-proof. |
Worst optical quality. Only half as clear as glass. |
| |
Lightweight. |
Very easily scratched. Shortest product lifespan. |
| |
|
click here for more about polycarbonate |
Comments About Glass
Glass is the only lens material that can be made into 100% optically correct sunglasses. For true vision, there is no comparison between glass and other lens materials.
Glass does not flex or compress. Whenever lenses are placed into an eyewear frame, they are held in place by pressure of some kind. Plastic lenses flex and that creates distortion; but that cannot happen with glass lenses.
Glass does not expand or contract in heat and cold in a significant way. No matter what the temperature outside, 100% optically correct sunglasses will remain 100% optically correct.
Glass is the hardest material, and the most scratch-resistant. Glass is the most durable, and longest-lasting sunglass lens material. However, it is not scratch proof. Sand can scratch glass, but it requires serious effort or trauma to scratch glass lenses.
Technology has made it possible to create a very lightweight glass lens. Today, it can be difficult to tell the difference between glass and plastic, even when holding a pair with glass lenses in one hand and a pair with plastic in the other hand. (Of course, the difference is clear when looking through the lenses. But the weight of the lens is no longer a dead giveaway as to which is which.)
The danger of shattering was once one of the major disadvantages of glass lenses. However, all glass lenses pass the "Drop Ball Test" for impact resistance - the same test that is administered to polycarbonate and CR-39 lenses. When today's polarized lenses tend to break in a similar pattern as a car windshield. The broken pieces of glass mostly stick to the polarizing film that is inside the lens.
These Spotters had been stepped on by the customer. Notice that the broken lens has retained its original curvature. The broken lens pieces were still so tightly held by the frame that we had to smash the broken lens out of the frame with a hammer (it took more than a few smacks, too!). This isn't to say in any way that glass lenses are equivalent to safety glasses. However, polarized glass lenses are much, much less likely to cause injuries today than they ever have been in the past.
Glass is the most expensive lens material.
|
|
Comments About CR-39
CR-39 is harder material than Polycarbonate,
and therefore less likely to scratch. However, all plastics
are softer than glass, and all plastics will scratch much more easily
than glass.
CR-39 is nearly as optically pure
as glass, which makes CR-39 the top of the line plastic for precision vision.
Unfortunately, there is no such thing as
100% optically correct CR-39 sunglasses. All lenses
must be held in a frame with pressure. Pressure applied to
CR-39 (and Polycarbonate) causes it to bend and flex. This
creates visual distortion. Your eyes are instruments of incredible
precision - and even a slight imperfection in the curvature of the
lens will affect your eyesight.
Unfortunately, many well known sunglass companies state in their
brochures or ads "100% optically correct CR-39." Or, "100% Optically Correct CR-39 Lenses."
That is what's known as "marketing slight-of-hand." Although what they state is true - the lenses are
100% optically correct - what they don't say is that, when the lenses
are inserted into a sunglass frame, they are no longer optically
correct. No manufacturer can solve this
problem. Nevertheless, CR-39 is still a better choice for
optical clarity than Polycarbonate.
CR-39 can chip in a way that is similar to glass. Although
every lens sold in the USA must pass an impact test (called the "Drop Ball Test"), if hit with a powerful impact CR-39 will break.
CR-39, like polycarbonate, is a less expensive lens material than
glass. Manufacturing plastic lenses is also less expensive
than working with glass.
Today there is only a marginal weight difference
between the best polarized glass lenses and plastic. Without
that strong advantage versus glass, CR-39 has been loosing popularity.
CR-39 retains its weight advantage against glass when it is used
in making strong prescription sunglasses (above +2.00 and below
-4.00 and beyond 4D). In those cases, CR-39 is the best alternative
to glass lenses.
|
Comments About Polycarbonate
Polycarbonate can split and crack, but it will not shatter. This is the same material used for industrial safety glasses.
Although polycarbonate is shatter-proof, it is the most easily scratched of all lens materials. Surface coatings are added to today's polycarbonate lenses to help protect them from scratching. Nevertheless, even the best hard coatings wear out, and polycarbonate lenses have a much shorter life span than other lens materials due to scratching.
Polycarbonate has several inherent properties that make it a poor choice for precision optics.
1) Impurities in the material itself which cannot be corrected for. These make polycarbonate naturally less clear.
2) Expands and contracts more than any other lens material in heat and cold. This creates distorted vision.
3) Flexes and compresses when attached to a sunglass frame. This creates distorted vision through the lens.
Polycarbonate is lighter than glass. Years ago, this was a major advantage. Now, glass lenses have become much thinner and lighter, and the difference is marginal. But there is a difference.
Every sunglass manufacturer (including Spotters Shades) uses techniques to try to improve the optical quality and scratch resistance of their polycarbonate lenses. No manufacturer can solve these problems, however. Polycarbonate is the best choice when safety is most important, such as in sports like skeet shooting. Polycarbonate is the least desirable material for visual acuity and everyday wear.
Polycarbonate is one of the least expensive materials and one of the least expensive lenses to manufacture.
|
|
|
|
|
©
2004/5 Spotters Shades Distributors. "Look
Sharp"; "VCE" and "VCE Process" are trademarks
of Spotters Shades Distributors and Spotters Shades Pty, Ltd.
"Spotters";
the Spotters Logos; "Penetrator" and "RubbaTouch"
are trademarks of Spotters Shades Pty, Ltd.
|